When is a pitcher charged with an earned run? August 22, 2018 22:53 Updated Please see the "Earned Runs" section on the MLB website. Related articles What is a Screw Your Neighbor League? When should a pitcher be credited with a save? How will I know when my league is ready to start? What time are the games simmed? What's the deadline for making managerial moves? If I have more than 1 pitcher set to the same role, how does the SimManager decide who to bring in?